Comments on: Talash-e-Haq http://www.pkhope.com/talash-e-haq/ A Candid Blog Fri, 25 May 2012 04:27:51 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.7 hourly 1 By: Qaisrani http://www.pkhope.com/talash-e-haq/comment-page-1/#comment-19888 Qaisrani Tue, 20 May 2008 12:01:32 +0000 http://www.pakspectator.com/talash-e-haq/#comment-19888 Dear Tariq what you lacked in the search for truth was prayers. You should continuously and patiently pray from Allah for His guidance and He will definitely guide you to the right path as he has guided millions. Dear Tariq what you lacked in the search for truth was prayers. You should continuously and patiently pray from Allah for His guidance and He will definitely guide you to the right path as he has guided millions.

]]> By: Farrukh Jamal http://www.pkhope.com/talash-e-haq/comment-page-1/#comment-13015 Farrukh Jamal Tue, 22 Apr 2008 09:58:40 +0000 http://www.pakspectator.com/talash-e-haq/#comment-13015 I studied your essays about Ahmadiyyat. As far as your opinion is concerned it seems that you are approaching positively. But phenomenan which you presented about the truthfulness oft Mirza Ghulam Ahmad sahib is totally wrong. You wrote in your Article that some people diverted from their belief about the prophethood of Mirza sahib. I am very sorry to say that you did not know much about islam and its history. 1- the Olama ( as you called 'em) who diverted did not refused his prophet hood. they called him Mujaddid, ummatee nabee. they did not deny his claim of Messiah, and Mahdi. 2- You said a big number of Ahmadis who deniied were very close to MIrza sahib. they never call them that they are denying the claim of Mahdi and Messiah. 3-- they only refused the the institution of Khilafat and later on many of them came back and converted again, except some. 4-- You quoted a saying of Jesus that a tree is known by its fruits and the fruits of Ahmadiyyat are very sweet. but for those who keep eyes.. 5-- on the last hajj of the holy prophet mohammad S.A.W according to the riwayas there were 124000 Sahaba. but just after the Death of the Holy prophed there were a rebellion in all over Arab. and thousands of them left islam and became followers of false prophets. it was Abu bakr who tried to get back all of them. 6-- many a people left islam even in the age of Holy prophedt. Quraan recorded it. see verses about jews and kuffars. 7-- at the end i will like to present a hadith it is in bukharee in the book tafseerulquraan under the verse falamma tawaffatanee( almaida) it says on the day of judgement some people of my Ummah were taken to the left( ie jahannam) on seeing that i wil say O my Lord they are my companios, it will be said you did not know what they have done after you. then i will say what a pious servant( jesus) has said i was witness of there deeds as far as i was among them but when you gave death to me you were their super visor. please try to be rational not prejudice. your sincerely farrukh jamal islamabad I studied your essays about Ahmadiyyat. As far as your opinion is concerned it seems that you are approaching positively. But phenomenan which you presented about the truthfulness oft Mirza Ghulam Ahmad sahib is totally wrong. You wrote in your Article that some people diverted from their belief about the prophethood of Mirza sahib. I am very sorry to say that you did not know much about islam and its history.
1- the Olama ( as you called ‘em) who diverted did not refused his prophet hood. they called him Mujaddid, ummatee nabee.
they did not deny his claim of Messiah, and Mahdi.
2- You said a big number of Ahmadis who deniied were very close to MIrza sahib. they never call them that they are denying the claim of Mahdi and Messiah.
3– they only refused the the institution of Khilafat and later on many of them came back and converted again, except some.
4– You quoted a saying of Jesus that a tree is known by its fruits and the fruits of Ahmadiyyat are very sweet. but for those who keep eyes..

5– on the last hajj of the holy prophet mohammad S.A.W according to the riwayas there were 124000 Sahaba. but just after the Death of the Holy prophed there were a rebellion in all over Arab. and thousands of them left islam and became followers of false prophets. it was Abu bakr who tried to get back all of them.
6– many a people left islam even in the age of Holy prophedt. Quraan recorded it.
see verses about jews and kuffars.
7– at the end i will like to present a hadith it is in bukharee in the book tafseerulquraan under the verse falamma tawaffatanee( almaida) it says on the day of judgement some people of my Ummah were taken to the left( ie jahannam) on seeing that i wil say O my Lord they are my companios, it will be said you did not know what they have done after you.
then i will say what a pious servant( jesus) has said i was witness of there deeds as far as i was among them but when you gave death to me you were their super visor.

please try to be rational not prejudice.
your sincerely
farrukh jamal
islamabad

]]>