The Pakistani Spectator

A Candid Blog

Breaking the deadlock of Kalabagh Dam with wisdom

By Guest Blogger • Dec 5th, 2012 • Category: Lead Story, Politics, Worth A Second Look • 5 Comments

The discussion of constructing of Kalabagh Dam has started again after the Lahore High Court directed the government to build it. Unfortunately in Pakistan, we got this naive rule that the province in which the dam is build would get its royalty. Now the problem with Kalabagh Dam is that it is built in city of Kalabagh, which is in the province of Punjab very close to its border with KPK. The proposed dam is affecting the areas of KPK and Sindh but will benefit huge areas of Punjab and some areas of Southern KPK also. Same thing happened in Ghazi Barotha Project that it is built in Punjab but it affected areas of KPK and of course Punjab took its royalty as well its benefits too.

Some people in Punjab are expecting population of KPK and Sindh to just shut up in case of Kalabagh Dam and think about the bigger interest of country and let Punjab get the royalty as well benefit from Kalabagh dam even if it has to sink parts of KPK and Sindh. Now rather then expecting this from people of KPK and Sindh, why not we all as fellow Pakistanis try to address their valid concerns specially the people who will be directly hit by the proposed dam. I guess Mardan, Noshera and Southern Sindh are as part of Pakistan as any area in Punjab which will benefit from it. I strongly believe there are very valid and just solutions available for that deadlock. First is that the borders of KPK and Punjab should be altered to add Kalabagh
to KPK and that how KPK will get dam’s royalty and it can be used to compensate areas which will be affected by the dam. Interestingly very few people know that city of Kalabagh used to be part of NWFP
(currently called KPK) before. That will definitely do not address the concerns of Sindh province. Second and the best option is to get rid of this obsolete rule where the the province in which the dam is built is going to walk away with its royalty even if it sink the neighboring province. That rule sounds as crazy and very unjustified.

The best would be that the dam royalty is distributed in all the affected areas of Pakistan irrespective of the fact which province it is located in.

Trackback URL

Tagged as: , ,

Click For More Articles By Guest Blogger
All posts by Guest Blogger
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

5 Responses »

  1. Very good point of view.

  2. Nothing is going to be implemented in this country. I am so hopeless.

  3. *Buss Daratay Jien Gay- = Just create false panic of War against Terror & transfer American/Brits & NATO aid into own personal foreign currency account.

    Pakistan Per–Mosalat Kerda–American Jung ko–MANTAQI–Anjam – Tuk – Pohchien – Gay-
    Record Pls. Merr Ker Bhi – Zardari & Co. Aisa Nahi – Ker Paien Gay –*Buss Daratay Jien Gay-
    Deikho - Aab - Iss American - JUNG – Kay –Asal Molzim –Aihista Aihista –Samnay – Aien- Gay-

  4. As if the CNG pricing crisis was not enough to disrupt public life, now comes another bombshell from Pakistan’s superior courts: the Kalabagh Dam. The LHC has ordered the federal government to construct the Kalabagh Dam, a controversial project that has been lingering on for many decades. This is the project over which three out of four of the country’s provinces have shown serious reservations. I wonder why the superior courts are wandering into areas about which they have little to no expertise. The court is a forum that is supposed to provide verdicts based on the facts presented before it. It should not be the court’s job to get involved in the economic and political management of the country. The court’s verdict on CNG prices has not only disrupted economic activity in the country due to non-availability of CNG at the price recommended by the SC, but has also adversely affected the government’s plan to reduce the gap between petrol and CNG pricing. The same is applicable to the court order for the delimitation of constituencies in Karachi, which amounts to unnecessarily inciting ethnic tension. The court’s next target appears to be the local government bill recently passed by the Sindh Assembly. Earlier, we witnessed the court’s unnecessary involvement in the ‘Memogate’ scandal. This turmoil is not taking us anywhere; economic and political decisions should be left for the concerned parties to take.

  5. Thank you for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more from this post. I am very glad to see such fantastic info being shared freely out there.

Leave a Reply (Read Comment Policy)

TPS has started observing minimal and mainly automatic comments moderation. Our automatic moderation tool tries to moderate comments on the basis of inappropriate keywords. If you feel that your valid and proper comment has been moderated, then please let us know, and we will promptly look into it. If you feel that an inappropriate comment has been ignored by tool, then let us know please, and we will check it. Thanks for your visit and help.

Like this facebook page too for the forms and application. Like page for FORMS and Applications